Dan Willingham, one of our favorite cognitive scientists, wrote a lucid critique last week of a recent New York Times op-ed that called for a more of what many people consider progressive education principles. The op-ed, by Susan Engel, director of the teaching program at Williams College, probably struck a chord with many early educators, and parts of it made a lot of sense. It argued that teachers should be encouraged to devote more time to reading stories aloud and having children do the same. It argued that student shouldn't be taught to memorize lists of facts or "isolated mathematical formulas."
What Engel's piece didn't do, however, was talk about the rich foundation of content that children should be exposed to.